PA Atheist Files Complaint Against Restaurant Over Church Bulletin Discount

July 4, 2012 Atheism Mark McIntyre Leave a Comment

An article in the Christian Post causes me to ask some questions. I’m not sure of the legal standing of such a complaint, but for me this does not seem like a case of illegal discrimination. The full CP article can be found here: Pa. Atheist Files Complaint Against Restaurant Over Church Bulletin Discount.

Imagine that a prominent atheist like Richard Dawkins wants to sponsor a contest where the winner gets a million dollars for the best essay entitled “Why I am an Atheist.” This contest would exclude me because I am a theist and I would not be willing to pretend that I am an atheist. Is this discrimination against me? In a sense it is, but in my mind, the person putting up the money has the right to place whatever stipulations he wants on where and how he gives his money away.

Every day there are contests which require certain behaviors to earn entry into the contest. Tweet this, like that, write a comment, etc. etc. etc. Are these discrimination? Yes, but I can make a choice as to whether I would like to participate. To participate, I must follow the instructions and perform the prescribed actions to qualify for the contest.

Many businesses use coupons or advertisements which offer discounts to customers when the coupon or ad is brought into the store. The business owner makes a business decision to discount his product to lure in more customers.

In addition, every business owner needs to determine his target market. No business can be all things to all people. A restaurant, in particular, must determine what type of customer they want to attract. Hooters is working to draw in a very different customer than Chuck E Cheese. This is business 101.

For a restaurant to make a choice that they would like to attract church attenders to come for Sunday dinner is a legitimate business strategy. What better way to do this than to use the church bulletin discount. In my mind this is no more discriminatory than a grocery store refusing to give me the discount if I do not have the coupon or my store discount card.

I’d like to make a suggestion to my atheist friend who filed this complaint. When I go to the store and there is a sale item, often the customer service agent or another shopper will have an extra coupon. I’m sure if you asked a few of the “church going” people if they had an extra bulletin, one could easily be produced. On any given Sunday we could probably find 3 or 4 in our various Bibles.

Also, after filing such a complaint, you better leave a big tip.

About Mark McIntyre

A follower of Jesus Christ who shares observations about how Scripture should impact the church and the world. Mark is the original author and editor of Attempts at Honesty.

On dealing with the chaos

There are days when the dysfunction and brokenness of the world can be overwhelming. Gardens grow weeds, governments migrate toward tyranny and rejection of the moral law seems to be the order of the day. In thinking about this today, a song lyric started running through my head . . .

Book Review: From God to Us by Geisler and Nix

This post is a review of the book, From God to Us by Geisler and Nix. A work that should be on the shelves of any serious Bible student.

This little light of mine – Thoughts on Matthew 5:14-16

Jesus words about believers being the light of the world are familiar to most Christians. What does it mean to be the light of the world and how do we go about doing it?

An Easter Meditation for 2016

If ever I felt the need to appreciate and appropriate the meaning and the power of The Resurrection, it is today. I thought that perhaps you would also benefit from this meditation as we consider the empty tomb.

Don’t be surprised by the tares

I’m writing this because a good friend of mine is struggling to recover from the betrayal that this pastor in a real church in a real city represents. I have a mixture of sadness and a tinge of anger in response to this situation. In praying and thinking about this, I was reminded about the parable of the tares.

Commission and commands – Priorities for the Church

The Great Commission is the foundational text on which the mission of the church should be based. Or is it? Is there something else that needs to take priority? I think there is.